The 10 Stages of American Civil War (And Where We Are Right Now)
When America Breaks, Episode 2
Christian Warrior Training | Christian Warrior Bible Study
DOWNLOADS FOR FREE AND PAID SUBSCRIBERS BELOW👇
There are ten stages, and America is standing in six of them
There are ten stages to a civil war. Six of them are already in motion in this country. Three are not happening here at all. The tenth is how these things end.
That line, the one that falls between stage six and stage seven, is the entire reason to read this. Which side of it you are standing on decides what you do about it this week. Under every stage below I give you the one thing your family should have already done by that point.
A stage model is not a prediction. Nobody can predict this and anybody who tells you otherwise is selling you something. What it does is locate you.
Before we start, three honest caveats
This pattern comes from wars that already happened, so it describes tendencies and not a timetable. Stages overlap and they run at wildly different speeds. Lebanon slid for years. Bosnia went from a normal election to a siege in seventeen months.
Countries also walk backward down this ladder, and that is the part the doom channels leave out. A nation can enter the early stages, sit there a decade, and come out the other side without a war. Recognizing Stage 2 in America does not commit you to believing Stage 9 is coming.
Some of you are going to call this fearmongering. I understand the objection and I would rather answer it now than in the comments. Matthew 24:6-7 has Christ telling His disciples they will hear of wars and rumors of wars, and in the same breath telling them not to be alarmed by it. He gave them the information and then told them what it should not do to them. That is the assignment for this article. Proverbs 22:3 says the prudent sees danger and hides himself while the simple go on and suffer for it, and notice the verse assumes both men could see the same thing. The difference between them was not information. It was what they did with it.
Stage 1: Sorting
The first stage looks like moving vans, not militias.
Sorting is a population separating itself into camps. It happens geographically when families relocate to counties where they feel politically at home. It happens socially when the Thanksgiving table quietly reorganizes around agreement, and when a man realizes he no longer has a close friend who votes differently. In Bosnia you could read the sorting off the 1990 ballot seventeen months before the first shell landed.
Why does this stage matter so much when nothing violent is happening in it? Because it removes contact, and contact is the only thing that keeps the other side made of people. Once you do not personally know anyone on the far side of a line, that side becomes a category in your head, and a category is a much easier thing to write off than Dave who fixed your truck.
America finished this stage a while ago. County voting patterns have grown steadily more lopsided for thirty years, and interstate migration now tracks politics in a way it plainly did not in the 1990s.
What your family should have already done. Write out who you could actually reach on foot from your own front door. Not your contact list. Who is close enough to matter, who would come if you called, and who is going to need you to come get them. Your parents, your grown children, the widow two houses down. Sorting has already thinned that list for most men and they have not noticed, because it happened one moved friendship at a time over twenty years.
Stage 2: The information war
Shared reality goes next.
Two men watch the same fifteen seconds of video and come away with opposing accounts, both certain, both with sources, and neither one lying. Rumor outruns correction every time, and the correction gets read as proof of a cover-up when it finally shows up.
Synthetic media makes this stage worse than anything Bosnia had. Their propaganda came from state television and everybody knew who was producing it. Ours arrives on a phone from an account with no name, and by the time anyone establishes the footage was fabricated it has four million views and has already put people in the street.
America is in this stage right now. Trust has fallen in institutions across the board, including the ones on your side of the aisle, and that is not a partisan claim because the numbers are ugly in every direction.
What your family should have already done. Put a rule in your house that nothing gets forwarded and nothing gets acted on off the first version of it. That applies to you, your wife, and every teenager with a phone. A family that reacts to whatever hits the screen first is a family being steered by whoever manufactured it, and eventually that steering puts one of them somewhere they should not be. Proverbs 18:17 puts it plainly: the first man to state his case seems right until the other one comes and examines him. That habit gets built at your own table in the quiet, because it cannot be installed in the middle of an event.
Stage 3: The spark
Every one of these wars has a date people point back to.
Lebanon has April 13, 1975. That morning, gunmen in a car fired on a church in the Christian district of Ain el-Rummaneh in East Beirut and killed four people. Hours later, Phalangist militiamen stopped a bus carrying Palestinians through that same neighborhood and killed twenty-seven of them. Fifteen years of war followed.
Here is the part worth sitting with. Marwan Chahine, a Lebanese-French journalist who wrote an entire book on that day, went looking for the planned operation and could not find one. He concluded the shooters were trigger-happy young men rather than an organized cell, and that the day only reached that scale because it landed on top of many others at a point when the state was already too weak to hold anything together. The spark did not cause the war. It landed on a country that was already assembled and it finished the wiring.
That is why predicting the spark is a waste of your time and preparing for one is not. Nobody can tell you what it will be. What can be said is that it will be ambiguous, that both sides will have a complete and confident account of it inside of two hours, and that the two accounts will never be reconciled.
America has had several candidate events in the last ten years that did not catch. I think that is the single most encouraging fact in this entire article and it deserves to be said out loud. The assembly is not finished.
What your family should have already done. Write down what your family does in the first twenty-four hours after a national shock. Who calls whom and in what order. Does everyone come home or does everyone stay put. Where you meet if home is not an option. What the kids do if it happens during school hours and the phones are down. One page, on the refrigerator, read out loud once by every person living in that house. A family inventing that plan in the middle of the event spends the first day driving around looking for each other.
Stage 4: Street-level violence
Stage 4 is disorganized violence between civilians. Riots, arson, assaults, property destruction, carried out by loose groups with no command structure and no objective past this afternoon. It concentrates in cities, burns out, and reignites somewhere else a month later.
Casualties here stay low compared to what comes later, and that is exactly why people underestimate it. The damage is not the body count. The damage is what every incident does to the people watching it on their phones. Each one recruits. Men who wanted no part of any of this start deciding they need protection, and then they start looking around for who is going to provide it. That search is the fuel for everything after Stage 6.
America has been through real episodes of this without moving past it, which tells us sustained street violence does not escalate automatically.
What your family should have already done. This is the stage where where you go and when you go there starts to matter, and your wife and children need to understand that without being frightened by it. Everyone in the house should know what they do if something starts near them, drilled once so it is not the first time they have considered the question. I will be blunt about the other half of this. Most men who read about Stage 4 respond by buying something. Buy nothing this month. Sit down with your family instead, because that conversation is free and it is worth more than the gear. Read Nehemiah 4:9 and see what the man did. He prayed to God and set a guard, both halves in one sentence, no apology for either one, and he was protecting his own household and his neighbors at the same time.
Stage 5: Federal and state confrontation
This is the stage that turns unrest into a constitutional crisis, and it is the hinge of the whole model.
The argument stops being between citizens here. A governor refuses a federal directive. A state declines to enforce a federal law or moves to block a federal agency working inside its borders. A federal court order gets met with open non-compliance by a state official, or the other way around.
Why is this the hinge? Because it forces men in uniform to choose. Up to this point a deputy or a soldier does his job and never has to answer the question. At Stage 5 the question shows up on a Tuesday morning as a specific order from a specific supervisor with a specific name on it.
America has real activity here, in both directions, under administrations of both parties. Sanctuary policies, refusals to enforce federal firearms provisions, fights over National Guard authority, litigation that ends with an official loudly announcing he will not comply. Almost all of it stays inside the court system, and the courts absorbing that pressure is the reason this stage has not advanced.
What your family should have already done. Settle your theology of authority before somebody makes you use it, and settle it out loud with your wife and your older children so they are not hearing your position for the first time on the worst day of their lives. Romans 13 and Acts 5:29 are both in the Bible and a man who has only ever thought hard about one of them is going to be caught flat-footed. Romans 13 says governing authority is instituted by God and that submission is the ordinary Christian posture. Acts 5:29 has the apostles refusing a lawful order from a legitimate authority and taking the consequences for it. Neither one cancels the other. Give that a few months of Sunday afternoons, because it cannot start when somebody is standing on your porch asking you a question.
Stage 6: Law enforcement and military fracture
I spent close to thirty years in law enforcement and I want to be precise here, because the version of this stage you see in movies is wrong.
It does not start with agencies picking sides. There is no morning when half the department drives off. It starts with attrition and selective enforcement. Officers retire the day they hit eligibility. Recruiting fails. Agencies drop below the staffing level required to answer calls, so they quietly stop answering whole categories of call. What a department will enforce becomes uneven, and the unevenness tracks local politics.
For your family the effect arrives long before anything resembling a fracture, and it is simple. Nobody comes for a while. That can be true in a county that is completely peaceful, and in parts of this country it is already true. I do not have a national number for response times I would put my name behind, so I am not going to invent one. Get your own.
Episode 3 takes this apart in full, including the sheriff’s oath and what happens to National Guard units.
What your family should have already done. Call your non-emergency line this week and ask the average response time to your address on an ordinary Tuesday. Plan against a multiple of that number, because that is what you will actually be working with. Whatever the number turns out to be, that window belongs to you. Your family is the first responder for the length of it and every person in the house should know their job during it. Then look past your own four walls at your mother, your in-laws, and the widow down the street, and decide now that checking on them is your job, and tell them so.
Stage 7: Armed group activation
Stage 7 is where the loose violence of Stage 4 grows a command structure.
Groups form with names, money, leadership, and ground they consider theirs. Then they start doing something almost nobody expects, which is providing services the government has stopped providing. Militias in Lebanon collected the garbage. Paramilitaries in Northern Ireland ran neighborhood policing and handed out beatings as punishment. That service provision is what converts a gang into an authority in the eyes of the people who live there, and it is why this stage almost never reverses once it sets.
Foreign money usually shows up here too. An adversary state does not need to land troops. Cash, weapons, and amplification pointed at three sides at once is cheaper and works better, and it has been the standard playbook since the Cold War.
America is not in this stage. There are groups in this country that would very much like to be, and the distance between wanting it and having it is enormous. Being accurate about that distance matters more to me than sounding urgent.
What your family should have already done. Understand that your safety at this stage runs through your own household and the people around it, not through a faction. This is where a lot of preparedness content goes badly wrong and I have no use for it. The answer to organized armed groups is not to go find one to join. It is a Readiness Team, and mine is made of family, friends, and neighbors, which is exactly what yours should be. Luke 14:28-31 has Christ telling two stories back to back, a man building a tower and a king considering war, and both of them are about counting the cost honestly before you commit to something you cannot finish.
Stage 8: Infrastructure failure
Power, water, fuel, banking, and communications stop working in the eighth stage, and they stop in that order for reasons most people never think about.
These systems hang on each other like a rope bridge with no redundant planks. Water treatment needs power. Fuel distribution needs payment processing. Payment processing needs communications. Pull one plank and the next three fail on a clock measured in hours, not days.
None of that requires an attack. Deferred maintenance, workforce that stops showing up, and just-in-time supply chains will do it on their own. Deliberate targeting only speeds up something neglect already started.
Plan around the household consequence, which is identical regardless of the cause. Your tap water stops being safe somewhere in the first week. Your food is whatever is in the house. Your money is whatever is in your hand. Episode 5 walks the first thirty days of this in detail.
What your family should have already done. Write down every person in your house who depends on refrigerated medication, powered medical equipment, or a well pump that needs electricity to run, then do the same for your parents and anyone else you will end up responsible for. It is a short list for most families and it is the difference between an inconvenience and a funeral. Put it on paper and make sure two people know where the paper is.
Stage 9: Territorial control
The ninth stage is what turns a breakdown into a war.
Ground changes hands. Areas take on a faction’s identity, and getting between them means passing a checkpoint run by men who do not work for any government. Movement stops being a choice. The sorting that happened voluntarily back in Stage 1 gets completed here at gunpoint, and every conflict that reaches this stage produces its worst atrocities in it, almost always against civilians, almost always committed by men from the same town.
America is nowhere near this. Saying that is not optimism, it is accuracy, and a model that cannot rule anything out is worthless for locating anything.
What your family should have already done. Nothing gets built at Stage 9. Everything that helps your family here was built during the first eight, which is the entire argument for doing the work now, while it still costs you nothing but a few Saturday mornings.
Stage 10: Settlement or exhaustion
These wars end. That is worth knowing, and the ending is usually ugly and slow rather than clean.
One side wins outright, which is rare. An outside power imposes a settlement, which is what happened in Bosnia at Dayton. Or both sides exhaust themselves and negotiate, which is what happened in Northern Ireland after thirty years, 3,532 dead, and something close to fifty thousand wounded in a country smaller than Connecticut.
This is the stage almost no preparedness content goes near, because there is nothing exciting in it. Burying the dead, feeding the displaced, and rebuilding trust between people who did terrible things to each other are functions the church has performed after wars for two thousand years, and it performs them through families that held together. So understand what you are actually building. The man who comes out the far end of something like this with his marriage intact and children who still trust him is the man his whole street ends up leaning on. That is not decided at Stage 10. It is decided by how he led his house through the first nine.
Where America actually sits
Run the list honestly. Stage 1 is complete. Stage 2 is active. Stage 3 has produced several candidate events that failed to catch. Stage 4 shows up in episodes that have not sustained. Stage 5 is real and is being absorbed by the courts, which is exactly what is supposed to happen. Stage 6 is measurable in staffing numbers across most of the country. Stages 7 through 9 are not happening here.
That puts us in the early middle with the brakes still working. Not comfortable, and a long way from a war.
So do the unglamorous things this week. Write your people list. Call the sheriff’s office and get your real response time. Put the twenty-four-hour plan on one page and hang it on the refrigerator. Sit down with your wife and settle Romans 13 and Acts 5:29 before somebody forces the question on you. Then work through the Ten Stages Tracker at the kitchen table and mark what you can actually see from where you live.
Proverbs 6:6-8 sends a lazy man to go watch an ant, and the whole lesson is in the timing. She gathers in the summer, while the weather is good and nobody would fault her for resting, because summer is the only time gathering is possible.
Watch, stand fast in the faith, be brave, be strong. ABCs. Always be carrying.
Next episode. Will soldiers and deputies follow unconstitutional orders? Episode 3 covers the military and law enforcement split, and I pull directly from my own career for it.
Christian Warrior Prepper produces nothing illegal, unethical, or immoral. Nothing here is legal advice. Know the laws of your own state.
PAID SUBSCRIBER DOWNLOADS
✅ Stage Assessment Workbook
✅ Household Dependency Register
✅ Complete Bible Study for You and Your Family to Prepare
Keep reading with a 7-day free trial
Subscribe to Christian Warrior Prepper to keep reading this post and get 7 days of free access to the full post archives.